From Mentor to Micromanager: A Leadership Paradox

So, I’m in this leadership role where I hire people who need enough training to qualify for a PhD. I dive headfirst into their development, pouring hours into their growth. Meanwhile, they remain blissfully unaware of the extra hours I’m logging—thanks to my exempt status.

But here’s the kicker: after all that effort, I get branded a micromanager! Apparently, when you try to guide someone learning new skills, it’s seen as a full-on invasion of their personal space. I mean, I thought I was being helpful, but maybe I should just send them a “Good Luck!” card and hope for the best?

Lately, I’ve noticed some employees have such thin skin that they react to constructive feedback like I just suggested they swim with sharks. When I ask them to fix an error, you’d think I asked them to solve a Rubik’s Cube blindfolded! So now I’m stuck in this dilemma: should I keep quiet and let them scroll through Instagram while they search for their next job (which, thanks to my training, they might actually qualify for), or do I step in and play the role of the overzealous life coach?

And now for the cherry on top: my boss casually mentions that former employees found me a bit “challenging to work with.” Challenging? Really? I guess they’ve never met a manager who believes in actual feedback! So, here I am, pouring my heart into training while trying not to become the poster child for “bad manager.”

And the stakes? Oh, just the small matter of potentially losing my job over a misunderstanding. So, if anyone needs a lifeguard for this training pool of miscommunication, I’m available—preferably with a flotation device and a sense of humor!


2 responses to “From Mentor to Micromanager: A Leadership Paradox”

  1. You’re so right about the importance of feedback. Of course, cruel criticism can be crushing. But when the tone is collaborative and about making things better, feedback is so crucial to professional development. If all anyone gives you is useless compliments, you’ll never get better than what you are.

    I also feel too often people think of feedback as a mistake they made in the past that they need to beat themselves up over. In fact, feedback is all about the future, about learning a better way to achieve your potential.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much for your thoughtful comment! I really appreciate your insights and I’m glad to know my post resonated with you. Your feedback means a lot.

      Like

Leave a reply to Naomi Carter Cancel reply